Finding Her Way, Losing Our Cool: Why Malala’s Book Hit a Nerve

Malala Yousafzai’s Finding My Way has sparked debate across Pakistan. Between admiration and unease lies a question we rarely ask: why does a woman’s honesty make us so uncomfortable?

The Book That Started the Conversation

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Malala Yousafzai (@malala)

When Malala Yousafzai released her new memoir Finding My Way, the conversation began almost instantly. There were headlines about romance and faith, every detail pulled apart for meaning. But behind the noise sits a quieter truth: this isn’t about one book, but about the limits we place on how women tell their stories.

For more than a decade, Malala has lived as an idea as much as a person, a name that carries pride, politics, and the weight of other people’s expectations. So when she wrote about herself rather than what she stands for, the reaction was predictably mixed: admiration from some, disapproval from others, curiosity from almost everyone.

When Honesty Feels Unfamiliar

In Pakistan, we honour strength but often misunderstand what it looks like. We know how to celebrate a woman’s endurance. We are less sure how to receive her introspection. Grace is valued when it is silent. When it speaks, it is scrutinised.

That is why Finding My Way feels so polarising. Malala’s reflections on therapy, marriage, and faith aren’t new globally, but in our context, they land differently. We are used to women telling stories of survival, not of self-understanding. Once they have survived, we expect them to stay there, steady and unchanging.

We love when women rise, but not when they evolve.

Her book unsettles that expectation. Not because it is defiant, but because it is human, a quality we do not often grant public figures.

The Cost of Being Seen

That is the price of being a woman whose life became public property long before she chose it.

In Pakistan, visibility is both gift and burden. It comes with pride but also possession, the sense that once a woman represents us, her choices belong to us too. We want her to embody ideals that feel safe and familiar. The moment she steps outside them, the ownership begins to sting.

Of course, public figures are not beyond scrutiny, but there is a difference between critique and surveillance. And that line, especially for women, is far too easily crossed.

Much of the backlash to Finding My Way is not really about content. It is about control, the same unease that surfaces every time a Pakistani woman speaks in her own voice, not through the filters of respectability or restraint.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by FEMINIST (@feminist)

The Space Between Admiration and Judgment

There is room to disagree with what Malala says. There is even room to question how she says it. But the speed with which that disagreement turns into collective outrage says something about us too. It shows how tightly we still police the line between admiring a woman and actually understanding her.

This is not about whether Malala is right or wrong. It is about how rarely women are allowed to be both celebrated and flawed. We expect them to represent us perfectly, and when they do not, we call it betrayal.

Every time a woman steps out of the story we wrote for her, we rush to remind her who she is supposed to be.

A Reminder, Not a Verdict

Finding My Way might not be the book everyone hoped for. It is not a declaration; it is a reminder of how uneasy we still are with women who speak for themselves. You do not have to agree with her to recognise what her story reveals: how hard it still is for Pakistani women to be complex in public.